Oyster Bay Estates Homes for Sale

Oyster Bay Estates Homes for Sale

Welcome to Oyster Bay Estates, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of South Sarasota, Florida. This enchanting subdivision offers a perfect blend of tranquility and modern living, making it an ideal destination for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a serene lifestyle near the vibrant Gulf Coast.

Oyster Bay Estates is characterized by its lush landscaping, tree-lined streets, and a welcoming community atmosphere. The homes here are a testament to quality craftsmanship, featuring spacious layouts, contemporary designs, and a variety of architectural styles that appeal to diverse tastes. With properties ranging from charming single-family homes to luxurious waterfront estates, there’s something for everyone in this picturesque community.

One of the standout features of Oyster Bay Estates is its proximity to some of Florida’s finest beaches. Just a short drive away, you can sink your toes into the powdery sands of Siesta Key or enjoy the stunning sunsets at Nokomis Beach. For those who love the outdoors, nearby parks and nature preserves offer endless opportunities for hiking, biking, and enjoying the beautiful Florida weather.

In addition to its natural beauty, Oyster Bay Estates is conveniently located near shopping, dining, and entertainment options. The bustling downtown Sarasota is just a stone’s throw away, providing residents with access to a vibrant cultural scene, art galleries, and gourmet restaurants.

If you’re looking for homes for sale in Oyster Bay Estates, you’ll find a variety of options that cater to different lifestyles and budgets. Whether you’re dreaming of a cozy retreat or a luxurious waterfront property, this charming community has it all. Discover your dream home in Oyster Bay Estates today and embrace the Florida lifestyle you’ve always wanted!

Newest Oyster Bay Estates Homes for Sale

$11,375,000
4 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ Oyster Bay Estates SubDv. ⋅ 34231 Zip Code
Some properties offer a view. This extraordinary 1.41 acre Oyster Bay estate offers an entire waterfront world of its own and is one of the best waterfront locations that Sarasota has to offer, with more than 430 feet along Sarasota Bay and a setting that feels virtually irreplaceable. Spanish and Mediterranean inspired architecture lends warmth, character, and timeless sophistication to this remarkable six bedroom residence, while its expansive shoreline creates a front row seat to spectacular sunsets, passing boats, and the natural beauty of Sarasota’s coastal landscape. With access to the Intracoastal Waterway and Gulf of Mexico, this is a rare opportunity for the luxury buyer who believes life is best lived on the water. Spanning more than 10,000 total square feet, with nearly all principal living areas on one level, the home was created for both grand entertaining and relaxed waterfront living. Dramatic ceilings, distinctive architectural details, expansive windows, and a spectacular gallery space with an interior fountain establish a sense of occasion, while multiple intimate gathering areas make the estate equally comfortable for everyday life. A commercial grade chef’s kitchen with professional appliances is equipped for effortless entertaining, from elegant dinners to large celebrations. The primary suite is a private sanctuary framed by beautiful bay views, featuring an expansive custom wardrobe and an indulgent bath with soaking tub, oversized shower, and dedicated massage and sauna room. Five additional bedroom suites provide exceptional privacy for family and guests, each with its own bath and generous storage. Beyond the interiors, the estate unfolds like a private resort. A swimming pool, tennis court, fitness room, billiard room, private office, three car garage, abundant storage, and permitted dock replacement create a property designed for recreation, relaxation, and life on the water. A new roof completed in 2024 adds further value and peace of mind. The address is equally exceptional. Oyster Bay Estates places you near The Field Club, Siesta Key, Southside Village, Sarasota Memorial Hospital, and Downtown Sarasota, offering remarkable access to world class beaches, boating, fine dining, shopping, arts, and culture while remaining tucked within a prestigious waterfront enclave. For those with an even greater vision, the magnificent acreage and extraordinary bay frontage also present the opportunity to create a completely new custom waterfront estate. The property may offer potential for division into two buildable homesites if the existing residence is removed, subject to verification and applicable approvals. With its commanding Sarasota Bay frontage, boating access, acreage, privacy, and coveted location, 1136 N Lake Shore Drive is not simply a place to live. It is the opportunity to claim an extraordinary piece of Sarasota’s waterfront lifestyle.

1136 N Lake Shore Drive, Sarasota
$4,995,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ Oyster Bay Estates SubDv. ⋅ 34231 Zip Code
A residence of sophistication and luxury, this exceptional home was thoughtfully designed to bring family and friends together—sharing good food, meaningful connection, and the enjoyment of elevated everyday living. Ideally located just 8 miles from Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport, 12 minutes to Siesta Key Beach, and 10 minutes to downtown Sarasota, the property is in close proximity to The Ringling, Van Wezel, Selby Gardens, Asolo, premier dining and shopping, The Field Club, and the Sarasota Yacht Club—creating a seamless blend of culture, convenience, and coastal lifestyle. Elegant yet warm and approachable, the home blends refined architecture with tropical elements, including stone columns, metal pergolas, concrete textures, and lush landscaping, creating a relaxed oasis unlike any other. A surrounding stucco wall enhances privacy, allowing you to unwind to the soothing sound of a tranquil fountain within a peaceful, secluded setting. The main living spaces were intentionally designed for gathering, featuring bead-board stained ceilings in the family room, formal living room, and dining area. The cook’s kitchen is both striking and highly functional, highlighted by a glazed pressed-tin ceiling, unpolished concrete floors, and views into the kitchen garden through multiple French doors and expansive windows—perfectly suited for both everyday living and entertaining.

1804 N Lake Shore Drive, Sarasota
$26,400,000
4 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ Oyster Bay Estates SubDv. ⋅ 34231 Zip Code
Welcome to Villa Meraviglia — A Home Beyond Imagination. An extraordinary Neo-Classical Italian Renaissance estate set on 1.22 bayfront acres in Sarasota's exclusive Oyster Bay Estates. With 146 feet of direct frontage along the sparkling waters of Little Sarasota Bay and panoramic water views, this remarkable walled and gated property is both an architectural living gallery and a warm, inviting home designed to be lived in, enjoyed, and shared. Completely reimagined and expanded under the guidance of a classically trained Italian architect, the residence draws inspiration from Italy's Villa del Balbianello and the iconic Casa Casuarina. A bold metallic gate crowned with a striking Medusa head introduces the arrival experience, while two additional gold-leafed gates provide secure access, including a private entry to the neighboring yacht club. More than 800 feet of custom perimeter wall creates a dramatic architectural statement and exceptional privacy. Spanning nearly 10,700 square feet of refined interiors, plus more than 4,000 square feet of additional air-conditioned space for creativity and leisure, the home offers gracious yet comfortable spaces for everyday living and entertaining. Four ensuite bedrooms, four full and two half baths, and dual Clive Christian-inspired kitchens accommodate everything from intimate family meals to larger gatherings. Venetian plaster walls, 23-carat gold-gilded millwork, hand-painted frescoes, pecky cypress ceilings, stone-inlaid courtyards, and imported Italian materials reflect exceptional craftsmanship throughout. The waterfront lifestyle is equally compelling. Layered terraces and lush gardens frame peaceful bay views and create inviting places to gather, relax, dine, and enjoy spectacular year-round sunsets. A private dock with boat and jet-ski lifts makes boating and water sports part of everyday life. The resort-style pool, octagonal pavilion, and beautifully crafted summer kitchen create an exceptional outdoor gathering space. The sunken poolside kitchen, featuring a concealed appliance lift, 100-year-old reclaimed Chicago brick flooring, a herringbone-pattern ceiling, and maple dining table, is a warm and welcoming setting for relaxed alfresco meals and time with family and friends. Intimate seating areas throughout the property offer beautiful views in every direction. The pool deck is itself a work of art, with marble imported from Italy forming dramatic geometric patterns inspired by classic mythology. Intricate mosaics surround the pool, while a Medusa mosaic walkway connects the pool area to the dock. Perfectly private yet ideally located near The Field Club and just minutes from Sarasota's cultural scene, fine dining, and Gulf beaches, Villa Meraviglia offers a rare combination of architectural artistry and idyllic coastal living. A home of extraordinary artistry - yet equally designed for gathering, entertaining, enjoying the water, and experiencing the beauty of Sarasota Bay!

1310 S Lake Shore Drive, Sarasota
$5,980,000
4 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ Oyster Bay Estates SubDv. ⋅ 34231 Zip Code
The Windemere II is an extraordinary luxury custom home meticulously crafted by Heritage Builders. This coastal contemporary residence with clean lines is situated on a very rare West-of-Trail lakefront estate home site. The exquisite two-level residence redefines custom home living, flawlessly blending elegance, sophistication and comfort. As you step in the grand foyer, you are greeted by an expansive, open concept living space that seamlessly integrates the living, dining and kitchen areas. The gourmet kitchen is a chef’s dream, featuring top-of-the-line appliances, custom cabinetry and vast walk-in working pantry. This stunning home boasts four bedrooms, five luxurious baths and two convenient half baths. The primary suite, located on the first level overlooks the sparkling lake and features a designer bathroom private outdoor shower. For those who love to entertain, the Windemere II does not disappoint. Enjoy movie nights in the dedicated media room or host family gatherings in the versatile bonus room. A private study provides tranquil workspace. Ascend via the elegant custom staircase or convenient elevator to the upper level, where you will find two additional en-suite bedrooms, a large bonus room with wet bar and fitness room. Enjoy leisurely moments on the balcony overlooking the serene lake. Step through the massive pocketing sliding glass doors to discover your personal lakefront oasis – a breathtaking outdoor living retreat with a custom pool and spa and a fully equipped outdoor kitchen. Gather around the fire pit, perfect for cozy evenings under the stars. The Windemere II is not just a custom residence; it is a lifestyle. Experience the epitome of high-end-living and schedule a tour today! Floor plan located in attachments.

1521 S Lake Shore Drive, Sarasota
Start Your Search