Bimini Bay Colony Club Sub Homes with Stucco Exterior Construction

Welcome to Bimini Bay Colony Club Subdivision, a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque city of Anna Maria, Florida. This charming community offers a unique blend of coastal living and serene suburban lifestyle, making it an ideal destination for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a slice of paradise in the Sunshine State.

Bimini Bay Colony Club is characterized by its stunning homes, many of which boast elegant stucco exterior construction. These beautifully designed residences not only offer a contemporary aesthetic but also provide durability and low maintenance, allowing you to spend more time enjoying the breathtaking surroundings. The stucco finish gives each home a sophisticated charm, perfectly complementing the lush landscapes and vibrant flora that define this enchanting area.

As you stroll through the winding streets of Bimini Bay Colony, you’ll discover a welcoming community atmosphere, complete with friendly neighbors and well-kept gardens. The subdivision is conveniently located near the pristine beaches of Anna Maria Island, where you can bask in the sun, enjoy water sports, or simply take a leisurely walk along the shore. Additionally, the area is rich in local dining, shopping, and recreational opportunities, ensuring that you have everything you need within reach.

Whether you’re looking for a primary residence or a vacation getaway, Bimini Bay Colony offers a unique opportunity to embrace the laid-back Florida lifestyle. Don’t miss your chance to call this beautiful community home—your dream home awaits in Bimini Bay Colony!

Newest Bimini Bay Colony Club Sub Homes with Stucco Exterior Construction

$1,850,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Bimini Bay Colony Club Sub SubDv. ⋅ 34216 Zip Code

An income-producing opportunity in the heart of Anna Maria Island. This 4-bedroom, 4-bathroom duplex sits on coveted North Shore — steps from the boutiques, cafés, and galleries of Pine Avenue and minutes from the Gulf's world-famous sugar-white beaches. Blue Lagoon operates as a vacation rental with a proven track record, a loyal returning guest base, and confirmed reservations already booked into 2027. The property features a large heated pool, private outdoor entertaining areas in-unit washers/dryers, and an on-site EV charger. The duplex can be rented as two separate units or opened via an interior connecting door to accommodate larger groups, maximizing both flexibility and revenue potential year-round. Bert Harris Agreement — A Significant Asset This property benefits from a Bert Harris Private Property Rights Agreement with the City of Anna Maria. When the city enacted its vacation rental ordinance limiting all short-term rentals to a maximum occupancy of 8 guests regardless of home size, many property owners successfully filed claims under Florida's Bert J. Harris Jr. Private Property Rights Protection Act, a state law that protects owners when a local government action reduces the value of their property. Through a negotiated settlement, this property secured the right to host up to 12 guests, well above the city's standard cap. This agreement transfers with the property and represents a meaningful competitive and financial advantage that cannot easily be replicated by new purchasers today. A true turnkey investment in one of Florida's most sought-after island destinations.

76 N Shore Drive, Anna Maria

$1,525,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Bimini Bay Colony Club Sub SubDv. ⋅ 34216 Zip Code

LOCATION! NEW STEEL ROOF! .19 ACRE LOT! RARE ARTISAN WELL! MOTHER-IN-LAW SUITE! Opportunity is knocking on one of the most desirable streets on Anna Maria! This rare opportunity offers incredible potential in an unbeatable location. Just moments from the beach, the bay, the community center, and the shops and restaurants of Pine Avenue. This 3 bedroom, 3 bathroom home sits on an oversized .19-ACRE LOT in the heart of Anna Maria. The property features a NEW STEEL ROOF installed in MAY 2024 with a TRANSFERABLE 50-YEAR WARRANTY, providing a major upgrade already completed for the next owner. One of the bedrooms functions as a private mother-in-law suite with its own separate entrance, full bathroom, and existing hookups for a kitchenette - ideal for guests, extended family, or added rental flexibility. A unique highlight of the property is the separately deeded ARTISAN WELL, which supplies irrigation water to the community center as well as neighboring properties. This creates both community value and potential tax benefits! WEEKLY RENTALS are allowed, making this an outstanding opportunity for investors, builders, or buyers looking to create their dream island home. The property experienced flooding and will require renovation/gutting, but the location, lot size, and valuable existing features make this a truly exceptional investment opportunity on Anna Maria Island!

306 Palm Avenue, Anna Maria

Start Your Search